Contributors or not to the Commission on Race and Ethnic Disparities report

 

Several “contributors” to the Commission on Race and Ethnic Disparities repot did not recognise “contributions” from them.

Is it not both good manners and best practice that if you cite someone as a contributor to a report then you should check the “contribution” that you plan to include with the contributor before publication?

This would be a way to check that bias has not been introduced by the reports’ authors. It also increases ownership of the end result.

If, as it seems, this was routinely not done, then the authenticity of all the contributions must be questioned.

The authors now complain at criticism of the report. If they have not involved contributors in this way, then the criticisms are for the authors  alone to answer.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Johnson departure - why, when, how, who & what next ?

Image
  JOHNSON DEPARTURE - why, when, how, who & what next? (1000 words) I have blogged bits of this in various places, so this blog post brings them together. WHY? Boris Johnson is arguably the worst leader we could have at this time. Thousands of people have died unnecessarily because of his mistakes; thousands more will die. We also cannot start to fix the Brexit blunders while the Blunderer-in-Chief is in charge. He persistently resists scrutiny and will learn nothing. #IDontBegPardon , we hear from him, which is why that's the title for our new book & CD. A change of Prime Minister, has the potential to save thousands of lives, and that on its own is a good reason to hope for this and to work towards it. We could get a new Prime Minister who is focused on the real job, not on enriching incompetent cronies in the way that the National Audit Office report shows that Johnson's Government has done. WHY WILL MPs SACK HIM? Most MPs want (1) to retain their seats - that's
Read more

9 reasons why I as a Christian, am in favour of remaining in the EU, and opposing the current Brexit path

9 reasons why I as a Christian, am in favour of remaining in the EU, and opposing the current Brexit path (4000 words) INTRODUCTION There are a number of reasons why my Christian Faith leads me to support remaining in the European Union. Of course it’s right to respect that other Christians support Leave, and I have sought to understand their views. It’s reasonable to say that membership of the EU or not is a means to various ends, and people may disagree as to how remaining or leaving would fulfil those ends. This is a practical question; Leave or Remain is not an issue where one answer or the other is intrinsically moral or immoral. I have searched online and have not found much written that covers my nine main reasons, listed below – hence this article. I would be interested in responses, particularly from Christians who support Leave. This is a personal view. But it represents a strong conviction. I  am not denying that others may have different opinions, but I do have
Read more

OPEN LETTER TO IAIN STEWART on Covid. Brexit, UK AID, Post Office, Integrity, scrutiny and leadership

  From: Mike Cashman Sent: 26 April 2021  To: 'iain.stewart.mp@parliament.uk'  Subject: OPEN LETTER TO IAIN STEWART on Covid. Brexit, UK AID, Post Office, Integrity, scrutiny and leadership   OPEN LETTER TO IAIN STEWART MP Dear Iain We corresponded last year and until now I have not followed up on those interactions this year. I am now taking this opportunity to write on these and other topics. I am afraid that the result is a 2000-word letter, but the issues are related so I have combined them in one letter.  There is a summary at the end. Let me say at the start that while you and I would often be on opposite sides of the argument, I have been vocal in encouraging those on my side of the argument to be understanding of those on your side. I have strongly made the case that we should not judge all Tory MPs by the actions of the leaders, and for some I am sure life has been difficult. I have also encouraged people to avoid the temptation to say “I told you so”
Read more